Students 'copy' life statements

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/education/6426945.stm

Degree applicants 'copy from web'

"Ever since I was eight..." Thousands of prospective university students are using the internet to cheat in their applications, analysis by admissions service Ucas reveals.
Checks on 50,000 personal statements found 5% had borrowed material.
Its study, by CFL Software Development, was done after the 15 October deadline for Oxbridge, medicine, dentistry and veterinary science applications.
Almost 800 drew on three example medicine statements on a free website, including a story about burnt pyjamas.
The Ucas application form includes a personal statement for people to detail their interests and say why they want to study their chosen course.
CFL, which makes detection software Copycatch, found:
370 sentences contained a statement beginning: "a fascination for how the human body works..."
234 contained a statement relating a dramatic incident involving "burning a hole in pyjamas at age eight"
175 contained a statement which involved "an elderly or infirm grandfather".As the deadline had approached the number of applications with borrowed material had increased.
Feasibility
The pyjamas incident features in the top-rated personal statement for medicine applicants on the studential.com advice site:
"Ever since I accidentally burnt holes in my pyjamas after experimenting with a chemistry set on my eighth birthday, I have always had a passion for science."
Among the advice, the website states clearly about example material: "The first thing to remember is don't directly copy any of it - not even a single sentence!
"The reason is, copying statements is plagiarism, and if an admissions tutor sees a statement they recognise they will probably reject you instantly."
Ucas said the proliferation of advice sites, some of which charge a fee for writing tailored statements, is what prompted its inquiry.
It was not planning to take action against the individuals who had apparently been caught copying, a spokesman said.
This was a feasibility study and it was going to consult universities on the best way forward.
He said individual institutions needed to assess applications to see whether there was anything "fishy" about them.
"Very few are. Most of those are just borrowing some material then adapting it.
"There's a difference between copying, and using the web to get advice on how to write the best personal statement - there's nothing wrong with that."
Integrity
Part of Ucas' message in publicising its findings is to stress to youngsters that the personal statement is their opportunity to stand out from the crowd, to differentiate themselves from others with similar grades.
Borrowed material is most likely to appear at the end of the statement or where an applicant describes why they want to study a subject.
Ucas chief executive, Anthony McClaran, said: "We are pleased to see that plagiarism is not rife in applications and that few applicants are paying to plagiarise.
"We take the integrity of applications very seriously and commissioned this work to investigate the potential for screening applications for borrowed material in the future.
"As part of our ongoing commitment to maintaining integrity standards we will shortly be doubling the size our verification unit, which is responsible for identifying fraudulent applications."
The research also looked for similarities in applications from the same school, but found "very little evidence" of this.
E-mail this to a friend
Printable version
SEE ALSO
Exams 'could beat student cheats' 17 Oct 06 Education
Student plagiarism 'on the rise' 11 Feb 05 Education
Exams agency probes web cheating 11 Jun 06 Scotland
Worry at web exam plagiarism rise 02 May 06 Wales
Students 'admit copying essays' 16 Mar 06 Education
RELATED INTERNET LINKS
Ucas
JISC Plagiarism Advisory Service
Universities UK
National Union of Students
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites
TOP EDUCATION STORIES
No winners in degree place fight
Academics denounce maths A-level
Parents worry about summer costs
getRssUrlStory('/rss/newsonline_world_edition/uk_news/education/rss.xml')
News feeds
MOST POPULAR STORIES NOW
function liveStatsTabs(newTab,oldTab) {

if (document.getElementById)
{
document.getElementById(newTab).style.display = "inline";
document.getElementById(oldTab).style.display = "none";
return false;
}
else if (document.all)
{
document.all[oldTab].style.display = "none";
document.all[newTab].style.display = "inline";
return false;
}
else {
return true;
}
}
MOST SHARED
MOST READ
Lightning delays shuttle launch
Arabic blogosphere begins to bloom
Saudi 'genie' sued for harassment
Shah Rukh honoured to be Dr Khan
Rail staff face 'smile police' Most popular now, in detail
MOST SHARED
MOST READ
Israel in 'Sabbath car park' row
US president sets Afghan target
Saudi 'genie' sued for harassment
Concert cancelled as boy stabbed
Most of Xinjiang dead 'Chinese'
Jacqui Smith 'quit over porn row'
Rail staff face 'smile police'
Woman teacher on sex crime charge
Week in pictures: 4-10 July
Obama speaks of hopes for Africa Most popular now, in detail